Assessment
Lying Pattern Diagnostic
Distinguish between protective and manipulative lying for a specific client and identify the clinical response each type calls for.
This worksheet helps therapists determine which of two clinically distinct types of therapeutic deception is operating — protective lying, organized around safety and shame, or manipulative lying, organized around relational control. The distinction matters because the confrontation that helps with manipulative lying will damage the relationship with a protectively lying client.
Complete this worksheet after observing a consistent deception pattern across multiple sessions. The diagnostic must precede the response — the clinical approach for each type is different. Review the completed diagnostic before planning any intervention directed at the deception pattern.
Lying Pattern Diagnostic
Client (initials or identifier): _______________ Date: _______________ Sessions reviewed: _______________
Description of the deception pattern What form does the lying take? When does it appear in sessions? How long has it been present?
Clinical indicators of protective lying Mark any that apply for this client:
- Shame responses (color, withdrawal, deflection) when specific topics come up
- Deceptions organized around topics with obvious personal risk: relationships, finances, behavior the client believes is shameful
- History of relationships where honesty was dangerous or costly
- Lying reduces or stops when the therapist signals explicitly that honesty is safe
- The deceptions protect the client from exposure, not from clinical direction
Notes: _______________________________________________
Clinical indicators of manipulative lying Mark any that apply for this client:
- Control-seeking patterns in other parts of the therapeutic relationship
- Lying that appears to manage the therapist’s perception or treatment direction
- Deceptions that intensify when the therapist moves in specific clinical directions
- False progress reports that redirect the treatment away from difficult material
- The lying appears to give the client something: control over information, influence over the therapist’s behavior
Notes: _______________________________________________
Current hypothesis: which type is operating?
- Protective
- Manipulative
- Both, in different contexts (describe): _______________________________________________
Supporting evidence from session observations:
Recommended clinical approach
For protective lying: Indirect acceptance — build the relational conditions that make honesty progressively safer. Do not confront. Create indirect access routes to the protected material. Allow the client to approach at their own pace.
For manipulative lying: Relational pattern analysis — understand what relational function the manipulation serves before responding. Set clear clinical limits around specific deceptions only when the relational pattern is limiting the work. Address from a position of clinical concern, not moral judgment.
Selected approach for this client:
Download with your practice branding at rapport7.com/books/client-lies-in-session
Generated with Rapport7 — rapport7.com